Mackie's really do make the driest crisps ever made. 

These would give the 'see how many jacobs crackers you can eat without water' game a run for it's money. I'd be pretty impressed if anyone can get through this whole pack without some liquid.

The Salt content is actually ok and tastes good. But the crisps are just too dry, and have the odd crisp that's been left in too long and leave a burnt taste in your mouth.


4/10

Last week I was invited to Brown Bag Crisps HQ in Shepperton Studios to have a little chat about crisps - and give theirs a try. Here I am with Chloe, a crisp lover who is pretty passionate about the crisps they make.

I also met Phil, of Phil & Viv who created brown bag. Both were really nice people who know their crisps so I was in good company.

The interview they did with me will be up shortly on their blog:  
http://www.brownbagcrisps.co.uk/brown-bag-blog/


Before the invitation, i'd heard very little about brown bag crisps - they have a limited amount of stockists, but among them are Harrods - which is a good representation of what brown bag are all about. They are crisps for the crisp connoisseur, I found that to be extremely clear when in conversation with Phil, who's passion in his quest for the best crisp flavours are extremely critical and well educated. I learnt many things about the crisp industry and what actually goes into making a good crisp, some of which I'll share in this brief write-up.

First up are Lightly Salted, and immediately i'm struck by the real difference in brown bag crisps. They are the only crisp in the UK to be cooked in Olive Oil (which is why they have the price tag that they do.) This really makes a difference, the flavour of the potato is brought out and it's a smooth, full & rich flavour that you don't get from crisps cooked in sunflower oil. The crisps are curly, but Phil tells me the reason behind this as it's not the usual shape of a brown bag crisp. This year has been very very bad for potato crops as Phil frustratingly explains, every crop is different and you have to adjust your method accordingly. Mostly - it's about perfecting the amount of time that the crisp is in the oil for, they have to experiment on every new crop to get the best out of the potato that they can. This year has been bad, so they've left them in oil for longer - meaning the crisps are a lot more curly.

As you may have noticed on my blog, the classics (Salt, Cheese & Onion, Salt & Vinegar) will never get over a 7/10. For fear of not spoiling that regime too much - Lightly Salted get a 7.5/10. The amount of salt is perfect, but it's the smooth flavour of the olive oil that makes this crisp as good as it is.

Next up are Sea Salt & Malt Vinegar, I open up the pack and take a mouthful of salt, wince and look up to see Phil's horrified face. As he probably well knows from my site, I give very very honest reviews and for someone who strives to make the best flavours above the rest and has won awards for his salt & vinegar, he was pretty horrified to see i'd found myself an unfortunate odd bag that had been over-seasoned. He quickly rushed to find me another pack, which was very different - and since taking some home I can say that it was just an odd pack so am willing to let it slide, as brown bag have won great taste awards two years running for this flavour alone. Which for a classic - I believe is a big achievement, people have tasted salt & vinegar thousands of times before...so why are these so good?

Well the underlying olive oil potato is still quite clear, the crunch of the crisp is almighty and satisfying and the seasonings are perfectly distributed. the vinegar has the right amount of sweet and sourness to it and the salt has a very full flavour to it. Which is a strange thing to say about salt but after noticing this, Phil tells me why there's a difference... Crisp makers in the UK get their salt from the sea and dry them in big oven in the UK. Brown bag have sourced their salt from the continent - meaning that it's not been oven dried - but dried in actual sunshine before it's brought over here. This makes a difference and is one of the reasons Sea Salt & Malt Vinegar has done so well. It's a great 7.5/10 from me.

So i'm halfway through their range and am pretty happy. The one thing I was scared of the most was meeting really nice people and then having to slag off their crisps. Luckily brown bag are such crisp lovers & connoisseurs themselves.

Now here is the real shock for me. Cheese & Onion has been done and overdone. This classic is the most favourite walkers (and so favourite crisp) in the world. So how can it ever been bettered? 

The word that hit me from the packet was 'Manchego' - one of the best cheeses you could ever come across. I don't think I can include these in the cheese & onion category. They are simply much much more than that.
The cheddar and onion is still there and good on its own, but the manchego shines through here and blows this flavour into one of my personal favourites.

A lot of crisp companies like to put their names to farms (e.g Piper's Lye Cross Cheddar & Onion).
Which Phil tells me, is something he will never do. He says that just like the potatoes, the cheese quality varies throughout the year. So he is constantly tasting the cheeses to make sure he is still getting the best flavour out of it. This is a great method that I implore. 

9/10 for Mature Cheddar, Manchego & Onion

So now to the finale, the very last crisp from brown bag. Oak Smoked Chilli.

And it's another success. What's been oak smoked here is actually the sugar. Most crisps have sugar in them to even out the flavour, but none of them have played with it in such a way as this. The sweetness to these crisps are addictive, the chilli kick is powerful and full (which hits you after 5 seconds) but it's nicely set off by the sweetness that really makes these crisps work.

9/10

So brown bag give a massive big sign off from me, they tell me they have a smoked bacon flavour on its way using real bacon (Phil wouldn't have it any other way) which I look forward to. Let's hope they get a lot more stockists in the future. I will be spreading the brown bag crisps word for sure.

Damn. Pop Chips are gooooood!

A healthy crisp that tastes this good is a rare thing to find, but pop chips have really pulled it off.

I'm just munching through my third pack of original (not sure how that happened?!) & I can't get enough. It's just a plain salted crisp, it shouldn't have so much flavour to it... but it does.

There's no oil involved when cooking these babies, they squash potato down into tiny little kernels, and pop them just like popcorn. It reminds of the fascinating addiction I realise I have when I'm in an indian restaurant and just can. not. put. down. the. poppadoms.
Which is essentially what these are, a potato poppadom. Without any oil you get a good idea of what the potato tastes like, and it's good. These aren't over seasoned and the crunch is a really satisfying one. 

I'm usually pretty hesitant when approaching snacks that are made to be 'healthy' as healthy and flavoursome is not a common thing to go together in the snack world. Props to Pop Chips.


9/10

So, first flavour from Boxer Chips, is the classic ready salted.

Only these are labelled as 'Savagely Salted, but not indecently so' and that's a correct statement. They are well salted but not in a overly bad way.

The first obvious difference in these crisps are the packaging. You open the pack to reveal a cardboard box, which then folds out and opens up to what you see above.. good for sharing! Quite an interesting take on crisp packaging that I think works very well.

The crisp is very thin and curly, which might give the perception of a vegetable crisp, but these are most definitely potato. They have managed to keep the crisp very thin but still have a really massive crunch (without being oily.) Very impressive to start to this range.


7/10
(remember this is very high for a classic flavour)

Good crisp, not enough salt.

Maybe it's just this pack, but for a flavour that is salt... there's definitely not enough salt. Potato is good, crunch is massive, oil is is tasty.. just lacking some flavoursome salt.


3/10

So... Welsh crisps. 

They've kept their range very simple and gone for the 3 classic flavours. 

Unfortunately my packets arrived pretty crushed in the post, dare I say this but - they could do with a little more nitrogen in them to help this from happening!

But i'm pretty happy with them even though they're in a thousand pieces, crisps seems to be thick enough to have a good crunch, maybe a little greasy but not offensive like real crisps .

Not overly salted and spread evenly over the pack.

I'm not one to give a high score for the standard classics, so this is pretty high for ready salted.


7/10

This is more like it from Kent Crisps, although not that hard a flavour to get wrong - after the last two flavours I thought they might be over salted. 

But it's the perfect amount and these guys really know how to give a crisp a massive crunch.

Salted crisps done well, very well.



7/10

So here's the first of the Fiddler's range and it's a good start.

The crisps have a massive crunch without being too oily, and the salt flavouring is just right. Not overly salty and evenly seasoned. 


7/10

"Too much rape"

So the crisp isn't overly dark like the black pepper (maybe that was a bad pack) but there's something still not up to scratch here. First off, they really are too thin, you just don't get enough crunch from just crisps. Secondly - there's way too much of the old rapeseed oil, this pack was super greasy. But quite a good salty flavour which works well..

So disappointing really, as they seem to of got the flavouring right, but thickness of crisp and oil levels are not up to standard.


3/10

'A class ready salted'


Like other fairfields - flavour is not overdone, but this is done to perfection. A perfect crunch and a good amount of salt.

7/10